
Donald Trump's return to the Oval Office has sparked intense speculation about the direction of U.S. foreign policy, especially in the Asia-Pacific region. While the 2024 presidential campaign largely focused on the war in Ukraine and the Israeli occupation of Gaza, the Asia-Pacific remains a crucial theater of geopolitical and economic competition. Examining Trump’s past policies and campaign rhetoric provides insights into his likely approach in 2025.
Unpredictability in China-U.S. Competition
Trump has consistently emphasized unpredictability as a hallmark of his foreign policy, particularly regarding China. His first term was marked by a "trade war" and hawkish rhetoric toward Beijing, coupled with significant tariffs on Chinese goods. In his second term, Trump is expected to double down on this strategy, maintaining tariffs and possibly introducing new measures to challenge China's economic and geopolitical ambitions.
This unpredictability, however, could also extend to other regional powers. Trump’s provocative exchanges with North Korea’s Kim Jong Un, including his infamous "little rocket man" comments, set a tone for his approach to diplomacy. While Trump ended his first term on surprisingly amicable terms with Kim, allies in the region remain wary of how his unconventional methods might play out this time.
A Reluctance Toward Institutional Cooperation
Trump's disdain for international institutions was evident in his withdrawal from the Paris Agreement and his criticism of organizations like NATO and the WHO. This aversion is likely to persist, meaning that U.S. engagement in the Asia-Pacific will hinge on bilateral or ad hoc arrangements rather than multilateral frameworks.
However, Trump has shown a willingness to cooperate when tangible economic benefits for the U.S. are evident. For instance, his renegotiation of NAFTA into the USMCA demonstrated a pragmatic side to his approach. For Asia-Pacific allies, showcasing clear economic advantages could be key to securing U.S. cooperation under Trump’s leadership.
Challenges for Regional Allies
U.S. allies in the Asia-Pacific face a more unpredictable and transactional partnership under Trump. His proposed tariffs and strong rhetoric against China suggest a hardline stance that could strain regional relations. Moreover, Trump’s inner circle, chosen for their loyalty rather than expertise, might limit the moderating influence seen during his first term.
Allies like Japan, South Korea, and Australia will need to navigate this new dynamic carefully. Their apprehension stems not only from Trump’s policies but also from the risk of sudden shifts or reversals in U.S. commitments.
Implications for the Region
Trump’s return is likely to accelerate competition in the Asia-Pacific. His focus on challenging China could lead to strengthened ties with India and the Philippines, leveraging these partnerships to counter Beijing's influence. At the same time, his "America First" doctrine may limit broader U.S. engagement, placing greater responsibility on regional powers to maintain stability.
Trump's second term signifies a potential pivot in U.S. foreign policy—a shift that will undoubtedly have profound implications for the Asia-Pacific. While his unpredictability remains a central theme, the region can expect heightened competition, transactional diplomacy, and a continued focus on economic leverage. For allies and adversaries alike, the challenge will be to adapt to a U.S. president whose next move is never certain.
Commentaires